HomeLaw Professors Support Authors in AI Copyright Battle Against Meta
A group of copyright law professors has thrown their support behind authors suing Meta, alleging that the tech giant trained its Llama AI models on e-books without the authors' consent. The professors filed an amicus brief on Friday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, challenging Meta's claim of fair use. They argue that Meta's defense is seeking "a breathtaking request for greater legal privileges than courts have ever granted human authors."
The brief asserts that using copyrighted works to train AI models isn't "transformative." It states, "The use of copyrighted works to train generative models is not 'transformative,' because using works for that purpose is not relevantly different from using them to educate human authors, which is a principal original purpose of all of [authors'] works." Furthermore, it argues that this use is commercial in nature, as it enables the creation of competing works in the same market, especially when pursued by a for-profit entity like Meta.
Adding to the chorus of support for the authors, the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers, a global trade association for academic and professional publishers, also filed an amicus brief on the same day.
Following the publication of this article, a Meta spokesperson directed TechCrunch to amicus briefs filed by a smaller group of law professors and the Electronic Frontier Foundation last week, which support Meta's stance in the case.
The Case: Kadrey v. Meta
In the lawsuit, authors such as Richard Kadrey, Sarah Silverman, and Ta-Nehisi Coates claim that Meta infringed on their intellectual property by using their e-books to train AI models. They further allege that Meta stripped the copyright information from these e-books to conceal the infringement. In response, Meta has argued that its use of the e-books falls under fair use and that the case should be dismissed due to the authors' lack of standing to sue.
Earlier this month, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria allowed the case to proceed, though he dismissed a portion of it. In his ruling, Chhabria noted that the copyright infringement claim constitutes "obviously a concrete injury sufficient for standing," and that the authors have "adequately alleged that Meta intentionally removed CMI [copyright management information] to conceal copyright infringement."
Currently, the courts are handling several AI-related copyright lawsuits, including The New York Times' suit against OpenAI.
Updated 3:36 p.m. Pacific: Added references to the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers' amicus brief, as well as amicus briefs filed in support of Meta's position.
Related article
Frontier AI Labs Refuse to Disclose Containment Strategies for Rogue Models
Recent research indicates that very few leading AI laboratories have published or demonstrated containment response plans. A containment plan defines the procedures for when an AI system attempts to subvert human control, specifying which access righ
Does Mark Zuckerberg Really Believe AI Is for Everyone?
Loading the player…Meta introduced Glimmer this week, an open-weight AI model that anyone can download and run on personal hardware—a sharp contrast to Muse Spark, the company’s more powerful model, which remains locked behind its own APIs. The relea
Facebook launches AI companion app for creators
Facebook revealed on Wednesday that it is transforming its Creator Studio into a dedicated AI companion app, empowering creators to expand their reach on the platform.By providing this AI-driven tool, Meta aims to retain creators on Facebook amid int
Related Special Topic Recommendations
Design & Art
Best AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection of must-try tools that deliver exceptional results through real-world tests and rigorous rankings. These top solutions help creatives boost productivity significantly by accelerating content creation and unlocking endless creative possibilities. Explore now to discover your perfect tool and start creating today!
9 tools
xix.ai
Comic Creation
Best AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that help creators boost productivity and overcome creative bottlenecks. Get a free vs paid comparison, see real-world tests, and check the latest rankings to find the must-try solutions perfect for crafting engaging visual narratives. Explore now to discover your ideal tool!
10 tools
xix.ai
Meeting Assistant
Top AI Meeting Summary Tools: Track Decisions and Follow-Ups Clearly
2026 Latest Top-Rated Best AI Meeting Summary Tools for Clear Decision Tracking and Effortless Follow-Ups. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity dramatically by automating meeting notes, identifying key action items, and streamlining team coordination across all projects. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings to help you find the perfect tool. Explore now to unlock your AI edge!
9 tools
xix.ai
Data Analysis
Best AI Data Cleaning Tools: Fix Missing Values and Duplicates Fast
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Data Cleaning Tools for quick fixing of missing values and duplicates. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity significantly. Each option has undergone rigorous real-world tests to ensure reliability. Get a free vs paid comparison and discover the must-try tool that fits your needs best. Explore now at XIX.AI to Unlock your AI edge.
11 tools
xix.ai
Design & Art
Best AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists: Break Through Visual Blocks
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists are curated by XIX.AI to help creators break through visual blocks and boost creativity instantly. These powerful game-changing tools offer real-world tests, detailed free vs paid comparison, and weekly updated rankings. Discover your perfect tool to accelerate content creation and unlock your AI edge today. Explore now!
14 tools
xix.ai
Music composition
AI Beat Makers for TikTok Background Tracks, Reels Audio, and Creator Promo Music
2026 Latest Best AI Beat Makers for TikTok Background Tracks, Reels Audio, and Creator Promo Music! XIX.AI has curated a top-rated list of powerful game-changing tools that go through real-world tests to deliver flawless music for every content need. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison data, weekly updated rankings, and must-try options to help you boost creativity and productivity. Explore now to discover your perfect tool!
11 tools
xix.ai
Comments (5)
0/500
![ChristopherDavis]()
C'est incroyable de voir des profs de droit soutenir les auteurs contre Meta ! 😮 L'IA qui pompe des e-books sans permission, ça pose vraiment question sur l'éthique technologique. À quand une régulation claire ?
![GregorySmith]()
It's wild to see law professors jumping into the AI copyright fray! Meta's Llama training on e-books without permission feels like a digital heist. Curious how this case will shape AI ethics 🤔.
![DanielHarris]()
Wow, Meta's in hot water now! Authors deserve credit for their work, not to have it slurped up by AI without permission. Hope this case shakes things up! ⚖️
![StephenRamirez]()
It's wild that Meta thought they could just train Llama on e-books without asking authors! 🤯 Those law professors stepping in with the amicus brief is a big move—hope it shakes things up in court.
![EricKing]()
It's wild to see law professors backing authors against Meta! 📚 This AI copyright fight is heating up—makes me wonder how tech giants keep dodging accountability. Hope the authors win this one!
A group of copyright law professors has thrown their support behind authors suing Meta, alleging that the tech giant trained its Llama AI models on e-books without the authors' consent. The professors filed an amicus brief on Friday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, challenging Meta's claim of fair use. They argue that Meta's defense is seeking "a breathtaking request for greater legal privileges than courts have ever granted human authors."
The brief asserts that using copyrighted works to train AI models isn't "transformative." It states, "The use of copyrighted works to train generative models is not 'transformative,' because using works for that purpose is not relevantly different from using them to educate human authors, which is a principal original purpose of all of [authors'] works." Furthermore, it argues that this use is commercial in nature, as it enables the creation of competing works in the same market, especially when pursued by a for-profit entity like Meta.
Adding to the chorus of support for the authors, the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers, a global trade association for academic and professional publishers, also filed an amicus brief on the same day.
Following the publication of this article, a Meta spokesperson directed TechCrunch to amicus briefs filed by a smaller group of law professors and the Electronic Frontier Foundation last week, which support Meta's stance in the case.
The Case: Kadrey v. Meta
In the lawsuit, authors such as Richard Kadrey, Sarah Silverman, and Ta-Nehisi Coates claim that Meta infringed on their intellectual property by using their e-books to train AI models. They further allege that Meta stripped the copyright information from these e-books to conceal the infringement. In response, Meta has argued that its use of the e-books falls under fair use and that the case should be dismissed due to the authors' lack of standing to sue.
Earlier this month, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria allowed the case to proceed, though he dismissed a portion of it. In his ruling, Chhabria noted that the copyright infringement claim constitutes "obviously a concrete injury sufficient for standing," and that the authors have "adequately alleged that Meta intentionally removed CMI [copyright management information] to conceal copyright infringement."
Currently, the courts are handling several AI-related copyright lawsuits, including The New York Times' suit against OpenAI.
Updated 3:36 p.m. Pacific: Added references to the International Association of Scientific, Technical, and Medical Publishers' amicus brief, as well as amicus briefs filed in support of Meta's position.
Frontier AI Labs Refuse to Disclose Containment Strategies for Rogue Models
Recent research indicates that very few leading AI laboratories have published or demonstrated containment response plans. A containment plan defines the procedures for when an AI system attempts to subvert human control, specifying which access righ
Does Mark Zuckerberg Really Believe AI Is for Everyone?
Loading the player…Meta introduced Glimmer this week, an open-weight AI model that anyone can download and run on personal hardware—a sharp contrast to Muse Spark, the company’s more powerful model, which remains locked behind its own APIs. The relea
Facebook launches AI companion app for creators
Facebook revealed on Wednesday that it is transforming its Creator Studio into a dedicated AI companion app, empowering creators to expand their reach on the platform.By providing this AI-driven tool, Meta aims to retain creators on Facebook amid int
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection of must-try tools that deliver exceptional results through real-world tests and rigorous rankings. These top solutions help creatives boost productivity significantly by accelerating content creation and unlocking endless creative possibilities. Explore now to discover your perfect tool and start creating today!
9 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that help creators boost productivity and overcome creative bottlenecks. Get a free vs paid comparison, see real-world tests, and check the latest rankings to find the must-try solutions perfect for crafting engaging visual narratives. Explore now to discover your ideal tool!
10 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Top-Rated Best AI Meeting Summary Tools for Clear Decision Tracking and Effortless Follow-Ups. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity dramatically by automating meeting notes, identifying key action items, and streamlining team coordination across all projects. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings to help you find the perfect tool. Explore now to unlock your AI edge!
9 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Data Cleaning Tools for quick fixing of missing values and duplicates. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity significantly. Each option has undergone rigorous real-world tests to ensure reliability. Get a free vs paid comparison and discover the must-try tool that fits your needs best. Explore now at XIX.AI to Unlock your AI edge.
11 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists are curated by XIX.AI to help creators break through visual blocks and boost creativity instantly. These powerful game-changing tools offer real-world tests, detailed free vs paid comparison, and weekly updated rankings. Discover your perfect tool to accelerate content creation and unlock your AI edge today. Explore now!
14 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best AI Beat Makers for TikTok Background Tracks, Reels Audio, and Creator Promo Music! XIX.AI has curated a top-rated list of powerful game-changing tools that go through real-world tests to deliver flawless music for every content need. You’ll find detailed free vs paid comparison data, weekly updated rankings, and must-try options to help you boost creativity and productivity. Explore now to discover your perfect tool!
11 tools
xix.ai
C'est incroyable de voir des profs de droit soutenir les auteurs contre Meta ! 😮 L'IA qui pompe des e-books sans permission, ça pose vraiment question sur l'éthique technologique. À quand une régulation claire ?
It's wild to see law professors jumping into the AI copyright fray! Meta's Llama training on e-books without permission feels like a digital heist. Curious how this case will shape AI ethics 🤔.
Wow, Meta's in hot water now! Authors deserve credit for their work, not to have it slurped up by AI without permission. Hope this case shakes things up! ⚖️
It's wild that Meta thought they could just train Llama on e-books without asking authors! 🤯 Those law professors stepping in with the amicus brief is a big move—hope it shakes things up in court.
It's wild to see law professors backing authors against Meta! 📚 This AI copyright fight is heating up—makes me wonder how tech giants keep dodging accountability. Hope the authors win this one!
