HomeJudge Criticizes AI Entrepreneur for Employing AI-Generated 'Lawyer' in Court
A man's bold move to use an AI-generated avatar in his legal appeal certainly caught the attention of a New York courtroom, though not in the way he might have hoped.
Jerome Dewald, a 74-year-old entrepreneur behind a startup claiming to "revolutionize legal self-representation with AI," faced a stern rebuke during an employment dispute hearing on March 26th. The issue? He failed to disclose to the judges that the person presenting his oral argument was artificially generated. Although the court had given Dewald the green light to submit a video, Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels was taken aback when an unfamiliar face, clearly not Dewald, appeared on screen.
"Hold on," Manzanet-Daniels interjected, barely a sentence into the avatar's speech. "Is that counsel for the case?"
"I generated that," Dewald admitted. "It's not a real person."
Dewald explained to *The Register* that the avatar, a "big, beautiful hunk of a guy" named Jim, was one of the stock options from an AI avatar company called Tavus. He submitted the video due to his challenges with prolonged speaking, but the court was unaware that the video was AI-generated.
"It would have been nice to know that when you made your application. You did not tell me that, sir, I don't appreciate being misled," Manzanet-Daniels retorted after Dewald's confession. "You are not going to use this courtroom as a launch for your business."
Recent AI Mishaps in Legal Settings
This incident is part of a growing list of mishaps where AI and legal processes intersect. In 2023, two attorneys and their law firm faced penalties for submitting fictitious legal research generated by ChatGPT. Similarly, the "robot lawyer" company DoNotPay was slapped with a $193,000 settlement by the FTC in February for falsely claiming that its AI legal representation matched the effectiveness of human lawyers.
These cases highlight the importance of transparency and caution when integrating AI into legal proceedings. As technology continues to evolve, it's crucial for users to be upfront about their use of AI tools to maintain the integrity and trust within the judicial system.
Related article
Google Photos brings Clueless's iconic closet to life with AI
Google Photos announced a new AI-powered feature on Wednesday that will soon turn photos of your clothes into a digital closet, letting you create fresh outfit combinations and even virtually try them on. The concept clearly draws inspiration from Ch
Notion transforms its workspace into a hub for AI agents
Notion, the productivity software company, is entering the agentic era.During a live-streamed product announcement on Wednesday, Notion—best known for its collaborative note-taking app—unveiled a new developer platform that extends the capabilities o
ElevenLabs names BlackRock, Jamie Foxx, Eva Longoria as new investors
ElevenLabs, the voice AI company, has disclosed additional investors in its $500 million Series D round, originally announced in February. These include institutional investors like BlackRock, Wellington, D.E. Shaw, and Schroders; corporations such a
Related Special Topic Recommendations
Prompt
Best AI Prompts for B2B Lead Gen: Automate Sales Outreach and CRM Scripting
Discover the 2026 latest best AI prompts for B2B lead generation. Our curated, top-rated selection helps automate sales outreach and CRM scripting, boosting your conversion rates. Explore powerful, game-changing prompts on XIX.AI and unlock your sales automation edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
Image editing
Free AI Fashion Model Generators: Create Realistic Clothing Mockups & On-Model Photos
Discover the 2026 best free AI fashion model generators on XIX.AI. Our curated list features top-rated, game-changing tools for creating realistic clothing mockups and on-model photos. Compare free vs paid options with weekly updated rankings and real-world tests. Unlock your design edge today!
10 tools
xix.ai
writing
Best AI Continuity Editors for Fiction: Detect Plot Holes & Timeline Inconsistencies Automatically
Discover the 2026 best AI continuity editors for fiction writers. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that automatically detect plot holes and timeline inconsistencies. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect writing assistant to ensure flawless narratives. Explore the top picks now at XIX.AI.
10 tools
xix.ai
Animation Creation
Top AI Storyboard Generators: Convert Movie Scripts into Cinematic Animatics Automatically
Discover the 2026 best AI storyboard generators at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated tools automatically convert scripts into cinematic animatics, saving you time and boosting pre-production. Explore free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect creative partner today!
10 tools
xix.ai
SEO
Best AI Redirect & Broken Link Finders: Automatically Repair Crawl Errors to Save Crawl Budget
Discover the 2026 best AI redirect and broken link finders on XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that automatically repair crawl errors to save your crawl budget. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect SEO solution now!
10 tools
xix.ai
Video creation
Top AI Video Creators for Podcasters: Convert Audio Waves into Engaging Talking-Head Videos
Discover the 2026 best AI video creators for podcasters at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated list features powerful tools that convert your audio into engaging talking-head videos effortlessly. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your visual storytelling edge now.
10 tools
xix.ai
Comments (12)
0/500
![JoseRoberts]()
Wow, this is both fascinating and a bit reckless! The idea of using an AI avatar for legal self-representation sounds like something from a sci-fi movie, but the reality check from the judge was necessary. It highlights a huge gap between technological ambition and practical legal protocol. Are we ready for AI lawyers, or is this just opening a can of ethical worms? 🤔 The entrepreneur's boldness is admirable, but maybe the courtroom isn't the best place for beta testing tech yet. This case will definitely set a precedent!
![PatrickMartinez]()
Esse cara tentou inovar demais hein? 🤣 Usar um 'advogado' de IA no tribunal foi meio que pedir pra levar uma bronca. Ainda bem que o juiz botou limite nessa palhaçada - automação legal tem que respeitar as regras do jogo!
![ChristopherAllen]()
Menuda idea más ridícula 🤦♂️ ¿En serio pensó que un avatar de IA podría sustituir a un abogado real en los tribunales? Esto demuestra lo alejados que están algunos emprendedores de la realidad. La justicia necesita toque humano, no algoritmos generando palabrería legal. ¡Qué vergüenza para este señor!
![PeterPerez]()
This AI lawyer stunt is wild! 😲 I get trying to shake things up, but using an AI avatar in court? That’s like sending a robot to do your taxes. Curious if this guy thought it’d actually work or just wanted headlines.
![CarlMartin]()
Quel culot de vouloir utiliser un avatar IA en tribunal ! 😅 Franchement, je trouve ça fascinant, mais ça montre aussi les limites de l’IA face à un vrai juge. Peut-être qu’un jour on verra des IA avocats, mais là, c’est un peu trop tôt, non ?
![JackHernández]()
That AI lawyer stunt in court was wild! 😅 I get trying to shake things up, but maybe leave the lawyering to humans for now—AI’s not ready to argue cases like Perry Mason!
A man's bold move to use an AI-generated avatar in his legal appeal certainly caught the attention of a New York courtroom, though not in the way he might have hoped.
Jerome Dewald, a 74-year-old entrepreneur behind a startup claiming to "revolutionize legal self-representation with AI," faced a stern rebuke during an employment dispute hearing on March 26th. The issue? He failed to disclose to the judges that the person presenting his oral argument was artificially generated. Although the court had given Dewald the green light to submit a video, Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels was taken aback when an unfamiliar face, clearly not Dewald, appeared on screen.
"Hold on," Manzanet-Daniels interjected, barely a sentence into the avatar's speech. "Is that counsel for the case?"
"I generated that," Dewald admitted. "It's not a real person."
Dewald explained to *The Register* that the avatar, a "big, beautiful hunk of a guy" named Jim, was one of the stock options from an AI avatar company called Tavus. He submitted the video due to his challenges with prolonged speaking, but the court was unaware that the video was AI-generated.
"It would have been nice to know that when you made your application. You did not tell me that, sir, I don't appreciate being misled," Manzanet-Daniels retorted after Dewald's confession. "You are not going to use this courtroom as a launch for your business."
Recent AI Mishaps in Legal Settings
This incident is part of a growing list of mishaps where AI and legal processes intersect. In 2023, two attorneys and their law firm faced penalties for submitting fictitious legal research generated by ChatGPT. Similarly, the "robot lawyer" company DoNotPay was slapped with a $193,000 settlement by the FTC in February for falsely claiming that its AI legal representation matched the effectiveness of human lawyers.
These cases highlight the importance of transparency and caution when integrating AI into legal proceedings. As technology continues to evolve, it's crucial for users to be upfront about their use of AI tools to maintain the integrity and trust within the judicial system.
Google Photos brings Clueless's iconic closet to life with AI
Google Photos announced a new AI-powered feature on Wednesday that will soon turn photos of your clothes into a digital closet, letting you create fresh outfit combinations and even virtually try them on. The concept clearly draws inspiration from Ch
Notion transforms its workspace into a hub for AI agents
Notion, the productivity software company, is entering the agentic era.During a live-streamed product announcement on Wednesday, Notion—best known for its collaborative note-taking app—unveiled a new developer platform that extends the capabilities o
ElevenLabs names BlackRock, Jamie Foxx, Eva Longoria as new investors
ElevenLabs, the voice AI company, has disclosed additional investors in its $500 million Series D round, originally announced in February. These include institutional investors like BlackRock, Wellington, D.E. Shaw, and Schroders; corporations such a
Discover the 2026 latest best AI prompts for B2B lead generation. Our curated, top-rated selection helps automate sales outreach and CRM scripting, boosting your conversion rates. Explore powerful, game-changing prompts on XIX.AI and unlock your sales automation edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best free AI fashion model generators on XIX.AI. Our curated list features top-rated, game-changing tools for creating realistic clothing mockups and on-model photos. Compare free vs paid options with weekly updated rankings and real-world tests. Unlock your design edge today!
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI continuity editors for fiction writers. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that automatically detect plot holes and timeline inconsistencies. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect writing assistant to ensure flawless narratives. Explore the top picks now at XIX.AI.
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI storyboard generators at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated tools automatically convert scripts into cinematic animatics, saving you time and boosting pre-production. Explore free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect creative partner today!
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI redirect and broken link finders on XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that automatically repair crawl errors to save your crawl budget. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your perfect SEO solution now!
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI video creators for podcasters at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated list features powerful tools that convert your audio into engaging talking-head videos effortlessly. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your visual storytelling edge now.
10 tools
xix.ai
Wow, this is both fascinating and a bit reckless! The idea of using an AI avatar for legal self-representation sounds like something from a sci-fi movie, but the reality check from the judge was necessary. It highlights a huge gap between technological ambition and practical legal protocol. Are we ready for AI lawyers, or is this just opening a can of ethical worms? 🤔 The entrepreneur's boldness is admirable, but maybe the courtroom isn't the best place for beta testing tech yet. This case will definitely set a precedent!
Esse cara tentou inovar demais hein? 🤣 Usar um 'advogado' de IA no tribunal foi meio que pedir pra levar uma bronca. Ainda bem que o juiz botou limite nessa palhaçada - automação legal tem que respeitar as regras do jogo!
Menuda idea más ridícula 🤦♂️ ¿En serio pensó que un avatar de IA podría sustituir a un abogado real en los tribunales? Esto demuestra lo alejados que están algunos emprendedores de la realidad. La justicia necesita toque humano, no algoritmos generando palabrería legal. ¡Qué vergüenza para este señor!
This AI lawyer stunt is wild! 😲 I get trying to shake things up, but using an AI avatar in court? That’s like sending a robot to do your taxes. Curious if this guy thought it’d actually work or just wanted headlines.
Quel culot de vouloir utiliser un avatar IA en tribunal ! 😅 Franchement, je trouve ça fascinant, mais ça montre aussi les limites de l’IA face à un vrai juge. Peut-être qu’un jour on verra des IA avocats, mais là, c’est un peu trop tôt, non ?
That AI lawyer stunt in court was wild! 😅 I get trying to shake things up, but maybe leave the lawyering to humans for now—AI’s not ready to argue cases like Perry Mason!
