HomeJudge allows authors’ AI copyright lawsuit against Meta to move forward
A federal judge has decided to allow a copyright lawsuit against Meta to proceed, though he dismissed a portion of the case. In the lawsuit titled Kadrey vs. Meta, authors such as Richard Kadrey, Sarah Silverman, and Ta-Nehisi Coates claim that Meta infringed on their intellectual property by using their books to train its Llama AI models. They further allege that Meta stripped the copyright information from these books to conceal the infringement.
On the other hand, Meta argues that its use of the material falls under fair use and sought to have the case dismissed, claiming the authors lack the legal standing to sue. During last month's court session, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria hinted at his reluctance to dismiss the case but also took issue with what he described as "over-the-top" rhetoric from the authors' lawyers.
In his ruling on Friday, Judge Chhabria stated that the claim of copyright infringement constitutes a "concrete injury sufficient for standing." He also found that the authors had sufficiently alleged that Meta deliberately removed copyright management information (CMI) to hide the infringement. Chhabria noted, "Taken together, these allegations raise a 'reasonable, if not particularly strong inference' that Meta removed CMI to try to prevent Llama from outputting CMI and thus revealing it was trained on copyrighted material."
However, the judge dismissed the authors' claims under the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (CDAFA), reasoning that the authors did not claim that Meta accessed their computers or servers, but only their data in the form of their books.
The lawsuit has shed some light on Meta's approach to copyright issues, with court documents from the plaintiffs suggesting that Mark Zuckerberg approved the use of copyrighted works for training the Llama models, and that other Meta team members discussed using legally questionable content for AI training.
Currently, the courts are handling several AI-related copyright lawsuits, including one filed by The New York Times against OpenAI.
Related article
Meta AI now responds to buyer messages on Facebook Marketplace
Facebook Marketplace introduces new Meta AI features, including automated replies to buyer inquiries, the company announced Thursday. The platform also leverages AI to accelerate item listings, summarize seller profiles, and now lets sellers offer sh
Meta signs deal for millions of Amazon AI CPUs
Amazon has secured a significant partnership with Meta, once again relying on its own custom-designed chips. Meta has agreed to deploy millions of AWS Graviton chips to meet its expanding AI demands, Amazon confirmed on Friday.Note that AWS Graviton
Meta's natural gas surge may fuel South Dakota's power grid
Data centers have grown so massive that their electricity consumption now matches that of entire U.S. states. Consider Meta's Hyperion AI data center: once finished, it will consume as much power as South Dakota.Meta recently announced funding for se
Related Special Topic Recommendations
writing
Best Free AI Undetectable Writers: Turn Robotic Drafts into Natural, Human-Like Prose
Discover the 2026 best free undetectable AI writers at XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list helps you transform robotic drafts into natural, human-like prose. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your AI writing edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
Image editing
AI Art Generators for Short-Drama Storyboards: Fantasy & Urban Romance Characters
2026 Latest: Discover the best AI art generators for short-drama storyboards. Our curated list features top-rated tools for creating compelling fantasy and urban romance characters. Compare free vs paid options, see real-world test results, and find your perfect creative partner. Get weekly updated rankings and expert insights from XIX.AI. Start visualizing your story today!
10 tools
xix.ai
writing
Best AI Scripting Tools for Radio & Podcasting: Write Engaging Audio Commercials
Discover the 2026 best AI scripting tools for radio & podcasting at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated list features powerful, game-changing solutions to write engaging audio commercials fast. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your creative edge today!
10 tools
xix.ai
Business
Best AI Contract Review Software: Spot Legal Loopholes & Compliance Risks Instantly
Discover the 2026 best AI contract review software on XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that instantly spot legal loopholes and compliance risks. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your game-changing solution for secure, efficient contract analysis. Explore the definitive guide now.
10 tools
xix.ai
Animation Creation
AI Anime Generator for Donghua: Create Web Novel Characters & Comic Avatars
Discover the 2026 best AI anime generators for donghua. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools to create stunning web novel characters and comic avatars. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests. Find your perfect creative partner and bring your stories to life today at XIX.AI.
10 tools
xix.ai
Comic Creation
Top AI Auto-Colorization Tools for Manga: Apply Flat Colors with Zero Consistency Errors
Discover the 2026 best AI auto-colorization tools for manga at XIX.AI. Our curated list features top-rated, game-changing solutions that apply flat colors with zero consistency errors, boosting your productivity. Explore free vs paid comparisons, real-world tests, and weekly updated rankings to find your perfect match. Unlock your AI edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
Comments (23)
0/500
![KeithMoore]()
Interesting case! The judge letting part of the lawsuit proceed shows the legal system is starting to grapple with AI training data issues. This could set a major precedent for how copyrighted works are used in model development. Authors definitely deserve clarity on where the line is drawn.
![GaryWilson]()
드디어 제대로 된 법적 대응이 시작되는 건가요? 🤔 메타가 저지른 저작권 침해 사례들은 벌써 여러 번 봤는데, 이번엔 좀 더 명확한 판결이 나오길 바랍니다. AI 발전을 위해서라도 합법적인 데이터 사용 체계가 필요해요.
![AlbertHernández]()
This lawsuit against Meta is wild! Authors like Sarah Silverman are fighting back, saying their work got used without permission. Makes me wonder how AI companies are gonna handle copyright going forward. 🤔 Big tech’s in for a rough ride!
![CarlJones]()
मेटा के खिलाफ यह कॉपीराइट मुकदमा लेखकों के लिए बहुत बड़ी बात है! यह अच्छी बात है कि जज ने इसे आगे बढ़ने दिया, लेकिन यह दुख की बात है कि इसका एक हिस्सा खारिज हो गया। मुझे उम्मीद है कि कैडरे और उनकी टीम अपने काम के लिए न्याय प्राप्त करेगी। AI और कॉपीराइट का इस तरह मिलना बहुत ही अजीब है! 🤔 लेखकों, अच्छे काम के लिए लड़ते रहो! 💪
![RalphMartínez]()
This lawsuit against Meta is a big deal for authors! It's cool that the judge let it move forward, but it's a bummer that part of it got dismissed. I hope Kadrey and the gang get justice for their work. It's crazy to think about AI and copyrights mixing like this! 🤔 Keep fighting the good fight, authors! 💪
![RalphGarcia]()
メタに対する著作権訴訟が進行するのは作家にとって大きなニュースですね！一部が却下されたのは残念ですが、前進できたのは良かったです。カドレイたちが自分の作品の正義を勝ち取ることを願っています。AIと著作権がこのように交差するなんて信じられませんね！🤔 作家のみなさん、頑張ってください！💪
Meta AI now responds to buyer messages on Facebook Marketplace
Facebook Marketplace introduces new Meta AI features, including automated replies to buyer inquiries, the company announced Thursday. The platform also leverages AI to accelerate item listings, summarize seller profiles, and now lets sellers offer sh
Meta signs deal for millions of Amazon AI CPUs
Amazon has secured a significant partnership with Meta, once again relying on its own custom-designed chips. Meta has agreed to deploy millions of AWS Graviton chips to meet its expanding AI demands, Amazon confirmed on Friday.Note that AWS Graviton
Meta's natural gas surge may fuel South Dakota's power grid
Data centers have grown so massive that their electricity consumption now matches that of entire U.S. states. Consider Meta's Hyperion AI data center: once finished, it will consume as much power as South Dakota.Meta recently announced funding for se
Discover the 2026 best free undetectable AI writers at XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list helps you transform robotic drafts into natural, human-like prose. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your AI writing edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest: Discover the best AI art generators for short-drama storyboards. Our curated list features top-rated tools for creating compelling fantasy and urban romance characters. Compare free vs paid options, see real-world test results, and find your perfect creative partner. Get weekly updated rankings and expert insights from XIX.AI. Start visualizing your story today!
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI scripting tools for radio & podcasting at XIX.AI. Our curated, top-rated list features powerful, game-changing solutions to write engaging audio commercials fast. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Unlock your creative edge today!
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI contract review software on XIX.AI. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools that instantly spot legal loopholes and compliance risks. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings. Find your game-changing solution for secure, efficient contract analysis. Explore the definitive guide now.
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI anime generators for donghua. Our top-rated, curated list features powerful tools to create stunning web novel characters and comic avatars. Compare free vs paid options with real-world tests. Find your perfect creative partner and bring your stories to life today at XIX.AI.
10 tools
xix.ai
Discover the 2026 best AI auto-colorization tools for manga at XIX.AI. Our curated list features top-rated, game-changing solutions that apply flat colors with zero consistency errors, boosting your productivity. Explore free vs paid comparisons, real-world tests, and weekly updated rankings to find your perfect match. Unlock your AI edge today.
10 tools
xix.ai
Interesting case! The judge letting part of the lawsuit proceed shows the legal system is starting to grapple with AI training data issues. This could set a major precedent for how copyrighted works are used in model development. Authors definitely deserve clarity on where the line is drawn.
드디어 제대로 된 법적 대응이 시작되는 건가요? 🤔 메타가 저지른 저작권 침해 사례들은 벌써 여러 번 봤는데, 이번엔 좀 더 명확한 판결이 나오길 바랍니다. AI 발전을 위해서라도 합법적인 데이터 사용 체계가 필요해요.
This lawsuit against Meta is wild! Authors like Sarah Silverman are fighting back, saying their work got used without permission. Makes me wonder how AI companies are gonna handle copyright going forward. 🤔 Big tech’s in for a rough ride!
मेटा के खिलाफ यह कॉपीराइट मुकदमा लेखकों के लिए बहुत बड़ी बात है! यह अच्छी बात है कि जज ने इसे आगे बढ़ने दिया, लेकिन यह दुख की बात है कि इसका एक हिस्सा खारिज हो गया। मुझे उम्मीद है कि कैडरे और उनकी टीम अपने काम के लिए न्याय प्राप्त करेगी। AI और कॉपीराइट का इस तरह मिलना बहुत ही अजीब है! 🤔 लेखकों, अच्छे काम के लिए लड़ते रहो! 💪
This lawsuit against Meta is a big deal for authors! It's cool that the judge let it move forward, but it's a bummer that part of it got dismissed. I hope Kadrey and the gang get justice for their work. It's crazy to think about AI and copyrights mixing like this! 🤔 Keep fighting the good fight, authors! 💪
メタに対する著作権訴訟が進行するのは作家にとって大きなニュースですね！一部が却下されたのは残念ですが、前進できたのは良かったです。カドレイたちが自分の作品の正義を勝ち取ることを願っています。AIと著作権がこのように交差するなんて信じられませんね！🤔 作家のみなさん、頑張ってください！💪
