HomeOpenAI's AI Trained on Paywalled O’Reilly Books, Researchers Claim
OpenAI has faced numerous accusations of using copyrighted material without permission to train its AI models. A recent study by the AI Disclosures Project, a nonprofit established in 2024 by media mogul Tim O’Reilly and economist Ilan Strauss, suggests that OpenAI may have used non-public books from O’Reilly Media to train its more advanced model, GPT-4o.
AI models, essentially sophisticated prediction engines, are trained on vast datasets including books, movies, and TV shows. They learn patterns and generate responses based on these patterns, not creating anything truly new but rather approximating from their extensive knowledge base. As real-world data sources like the public web become exhausted, some AI labs, including OpenAI, have started using AI-generated data for training, though few have completely abandoned real-world data due to the risks of degrading model performance.
The AI Disclosures Project's paper claims that OpenAI's GPT-4o model, which is the default in ChatGPT, shows a strong recognition of content from paywalled O’Reilly books, unlike the earlier GPT-3.5 Turbo model. The paper suggests that GPT-4o was likely trained on these non-public books, despite O’Reilly Media not having a licensing agreement with OpenAI.
The study employed a method called DE-COP, introduced in 2024, to detect copyrighted content in AI training data. This "membership inference attack" tests whether a model can distinguish between human-authored texts and AI-generated paraphrases, indicating prior knowledge of the text if it can do so reliably. The researchers tested GPT-4o, GPT-3.5 Turbo, and other OpenAI models using 13,962 paragraph excerpts from 34 O’Reilly books, finding that GPT-4o recognized significantly more paywalled content than the older models.
While the authors acknowledge that their method isn't foolproof and that the paywalled content might have been introduced by users copying and pasting into ChatGPT, the findings raise questions about OpenAI's data practices. The study did not evaluate OpenAI's latest models, such as GPT-4.5 and reasoning models like o3-mini and o1, leaving open the possibility that these might not have been trained on the same data.
OpenAI has been pushing for more relaxed copyright laws regarding AI training data and has been seeking higher-quality data sources. The company has even hired journalists to refine its models' outputs, a practice seen across the AI industry where experts in various fields are recruited to enhance AI systems.
OpenAI does pay for some of its training data, having licensing agreements with various content providers and offering opt-out mechanisms for copyright owners. However, as the company faces legal challenges over its data practices, the findings of the O’Reilly paper cast a shadow over its operations.
OpenAI did not respond to requests for comment on the study.
Related article
OpenAI launches safer ChatGPT for teens years after they started using it
Following a series of lawsuits regarding the absence of safety protocols in AI chatbots—which contributed to teen suicides and other mental health crises—OpenAI unveiled ChatGPT for Teens on Monday. This new offering incorporates enhanced safety feat
Frontier AI Labs Refuse to Disclose Containment Strategies for Rogue Models
Recent research indicates that very few leading AI laboratories have published or demonstrated containment response plans. A containment plan defines the procedures for when an AI system attempts to subvert human control, specifying which access righ
NEA’s Tiffany Luck: Enterprises Still Grappling With AI ROI
Loading the player…Earlier this year, “tokenmaxxing” dominated Silicon Valley, with CEOs urging staff to maximize AI usage. That enthusiasm quickly met reality. Uber reportedly exceeded its annual AI budget within months, some firms reduced Claude li
Related Special Topic Recommendations
chatbot
Best AI Conversation Trainer Tools for Interview Practice
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Conversation Trainer Tools for Interview Practice are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that go through rigorous real-world tests to deliver accurate feedback. You’ll find a free vs paid comparison and detailed rankings to help you choose the must-try option that boosts your confidence and skills. Explore now to Discover your perfect tool for interview success!
12 tools
xix.ai
Design & Art
Best AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection of must-try tools that deliver exceptional results through real-world tests and rigorous rankings. These top solutions help creatives boost productivity significantly by accelerating content creation and unlocking endless creative possibilities. Explore now to discover your perfect tool and start creating today!
9 tools
xix.ai
Comic Creation
Best AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that help creators boost productivity and overcome creative bottlenecks. Get a free vs paid comparison, see real-world tests, and check the latest rankings to find the must-try solutions perfect for crafting engaging visual narratives. Explore now to discover your ideal tool!
10 tools
xix.ai
Meeting Assistant
Top AI Meeting Summary Tools: Track Decisions and Follow-Ups Clearly
2026 Latest Top-Rated Best AI Meeting Summary Tools for Clear Decision Tracking and Effortless Follow-Ups. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity dramatically by automating meeting notes, identifying key action items, and streamlining team coordination across all projects. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings to help you find the perfect tool. Explore now to unlock your AI edge!
9 tools
xix.ai
Data Analysis
Best AI Data Cleaning Tools: Fix Missing Values and Duplicates Fast
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Data Cleaning Tools for quick fixing of missing values and duplicates. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity significantly. Each option has undergone rigorous real-world tests to ensure reliability. Get a free vs paid comparison and discover the must-try tool that fits your needs best. Explore now at XIX.AI to Unlock your AI edge.
11 tools
xix.ai
Design & Art
Best AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists: Break Through Visual Blocks
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists are curated by XIX.AI to help creators break through visual blocks and boost creativity instantly. These powerful game-changing tools offer real-world tests, detailed free vs paid comparison, and weekly updated rankings. Discover your perfect tool to accelerate content creation and unlock your AI edge today. Explore now!
14 tools
xix.ai
Comments (42)
0/500
![RichardJackson]()
こんなことされてしまうと、著作権料を払って制作している出版社側はたまったもんじゃないよね…AIの学習データの透明性、もっと求められるべきだと思う。🤔
![PeterNelson]()
This is wild! OpenAI sneaking in paywalled books to train their AI? Sounds like a plot twist from a sci-fi novel. Curious how they'll dodge this one—ethics in AI is getting messier by the day! 😅
![HarperJones]()
OpenAI가 유료 책을 이용해 AI를 훈련했다니 좀 의심스럽네요. 한편으론 AI 성능이 인상적이지만, 데이터 소스를 더 나은 방법으로 찾아야 할 것 같아요. 🤔
![WalterWhite]()
OpenAIの件については少し悩んでいます。O’Reillyの本を無断で使うのはちょっと気持ち悪いですが、彼らが作っているAIはかなりクールですね。次回は本の使用料を払うべきかも？🤔
![BruceClark]()
OpenAIが有料の書籍を使ってAIを訓練しているのは少し問題があるかもしれません。でも、AIの性能は本当に素晴らしいですね。データのソースをより良い方法で見つける必要があると思います。🤔
![DennisGarcia]()
I'm kinda torn about this OpenAI thing. On one hand, using those O’Reilly books without permission feels a bit off, you know? But on the other hand, the AI they're building is pretty slick! Maybe they should just pay for the books next time? 🤔
OpenAI launches safer ChatGPT for teens years after they started using it
Following a series of lawsuits regarding the absence of safety protocols in AI chatbots—which contributed to teen suicides and other mental health crises—OpenAI unveiled ChatGPT for Teens on Monday. This new offering incorporates enhanced safety feat
Frontier AI Labs Refuse to Disclose Containment Strategies for Rogue Models
Recent research indicates that very few leading AI laboratories have published or demonstrated containment response plans. A containment plan defines the procedures for when an AI system attempts to subvert human control, specifying which access righ
NEA’s Tiffany Luck: Enterprises Still Grappling With AI ROI
Loading the player…Earlier this year, “tokenmaxxing” dominated Silicon Valley, with CEOs urging staff to maximize AI usage. That enthusiasm quickly met reality. Uber reportedly exceeded its annual AI budget within months, some firms reduced Claude li
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Conversation Trainer Tools for Interview Practice are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that go through rigorous real-world tests to deliver accurate feedback. You’ll find a free vs paid comparison and detailed rankings to help you choose the must-try option that boosts your confidence and skills. Explore now to Discover your perfect tool for interview success!
12 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Style Transfer Tools for Creative Experiments! XIX.AI has curated a powerful, game-changing collection of must-try tools that deliver exceptional results through real-world tests and rigorous rankings. These top solutions help creatives boost productivity significantly by accelerating content creation and unlocking endless creative possibilities. Explore now to discover your perfect tool and start creating today!
9 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Dialogue Bubble Tools for Visual Storytelling are here on XIX.AI! This curated collection features powerful, game-changing tools that help creators boost productivity and overcome creative bottlenecks. Get a free vs paid comparison, see real-world tests, and check the latest rankings to find the must-try solutions perfect for crafting engaging visual narratives. Explore now to discover your ideal tool!
10 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Top-Rated Best AI Meeting Summary Tools for Clear Decision Tracking and Effortless Follow-Ups. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity dramatically by automating meeting notes, identifying key action items, and streamlining team coordination across all projects. Get a free vs paid comparison along with real-world tests and weekly updated rankings to help you find the perfect tool. Explore now to unlock your AI edge!
9 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-rated AI Data Cleaning Tools for quick fixing of missing values and duplicates. This curated list showcases powerful, game-changing solutions that boost productivity significantly. Each option has undergone rigorous real-world tests to ensure reliability. Get a free vs paid comparison and discover the must-try tool that fits your needs best. Explore now at XIX.AI to Unlock your AI edge.
11 tools
xix.ai
2026 Latest Best Top-Rated AI Creative Ideation Tools for Artists are curated by XIX.AI to help creators break through visual blocks and boost creativity instantly. These powerful game-changing tools offer real-world tests, detailed free vs paid comparison, and weekly updated rankings. Discover your perfect tool to accelerate content creation and unlock your AI edge today. Explore now!
14 tools
xix.ai
こんなことされてしまうと、著作権料を払って制作している出版社側はたまったもんじゃないよね…AIの学習データの透明性、もっと求められるべきだと思う。🤔
This is wild! OpenAI sneaking in paywalled books to train their AI? Sounds like a plot twist from a sci-fi novel. Curious how they'll dodge this one—ethics in AI is getting messier by the day! 😅
OpenAI가 유료 책을 이용해 AI를 훈련했다니 좀 의심스럽네요. 한편으론 AI 성능이 인상적이지만, 데이터 소스를 더 나은 방법으로 찾아야 할 것 같아요. 🤔
OpenAIの件については少し悩んでいます。O’Reillyの本を無断で使うのはちょっと気持ち悪いですが、彼らが作っているAIはかなりクールですね。次回は本の使用料を払うべきかも？🤔
OpenAIが有料の書籍を使ってAIを訓練しているのは少し問題があるかもしれません。でも、AIの性能は本当に素晴らしいですね。データのソースをより良い方法で見つける必要があると思います。🤔
I'm kinda torn about this OpenAI thing. On one hand, using those O’Reilly books without permission feels a bit off, you know? But on the other hand, the AI they're building is pretty slick! Maybe they should just pay for the books next time? 🤔
